Header Ads

ad

CANADA VERSUS USA TRADE WAR

 

There's no doubt in most Canadian minds that the Doug Ford Ontario ads using MAGA icon Reagan were poorly timed and poorly thought-out along with context truncated.

.

There are long standing issues between neighbours that predate Trump. 

Aluminum

Lumber

Steel

.

Here's the state of affairs:

 

The United States does not produce enough primary aluminum to meet its own needs. The domestic primary aluminum industry is insufficient to cover the country's demand, resulting in a significant reliance on imports, primarily from Canada.

In 2024, the U.S. produced approximately 680,000 tonnes of primary aluminum, operating at only 50% of its 1.36 million tonne capacity, while importing over 4.8 million tonnes of crude and semi-manufactured aluminum products.

Canada supplies about 60% of the primary aluminum used by the U.S. and 58% of all aluminum imports, making it a crucial supplier.

The U.S. industry has declined from having over 30 smelters in 1980 to only four operating smelters today, with three smelters closing or curtailing operations since 2018.

This decline is largely due to the high cost of electricity, which accounts for up to 40-50% of production costs, making U.S. smelters less competitive compared to Canadian facilities that use low-cost hydroelectric power.

While the U.S. has a strong secondary (recycled) aluminum industry, which produced 3.3 million tonnes in 2023, this is not enough to offset the shortfall in primary production.

The U.S. is therefore a net importer of aluminum, with its domestic production capacity unable to meet the demands of sectors like automotive, infrastructure, and clean energy.

........

The United States does not currently produce enough softwood lumber to meet its own domestic demand. In 2024, the U.S. produced approximately 72% of its lumber domestically, meaning it still relies on imports for the remaining 28%.

Canada is the primary source, supplying 28.1 million cubic meters of lumber in 2024, which accounts for 84.3% of all softwood lumber imports into the U.S..

While U.S. production capacity has increased significantly since 2016, with the addition of eight billion board feet of capacity and the production of 30 billion additional board feet of softwood lumber, the U.S. still falls short of fully meeting its needs without Canadian imports.

Industry analysis indicates that the U.S. lacks the existing capacity to fill the gap left by Canadian supply in the short term, as Canada currently supplies about 12.0 billion board feet of softwood lumber to the U.S. market, and the U.S. is still short by over 3.2 billion board feet of operable capacity to meet current demand levels.

Although the U.S. can supply up to 95% of its own lumber needs according to the U.S. Lumber Coalition, this still leaves a significant shortfall that requires Canadian imports.
.
You got to hand it the the US Lumber Coalition... they want a closed market so there's no price competition

 .........

The United States does not produce enough steel to meet its own domestic needs. The country imports a significant portion of its steel, with about 20% of the steel used in the U.S. in 2023 being imported according to Census Bureau data.

While the U.S. is the third-largest producer of steel globally, behind China and Japan, its production capacity is insufficient to cover total domestic consumption.

This reliance on imports makes U.S. industries vulnerable to global supply chain disruptions, particularly during trade disputes and tariff conflicts.

Although the U.S. produces 75% of its own steel needs, the remaining 25% must be imported, and the domestic industry faces challenges such as outdated infrastructure, high production costs, and competition from foreign producers.
.
Wouldn't you rather have Canadian steel with better quality than from China?

 There's gong to be a deal but personalities are burning bridges.

by  Ross Vaughan 
.
From publicly available research.